This essay analyses how Joker (2019) inverts concepts like good and evil to create an intoxicating, multi-layered film. SPOILERS.
Arthur Fleck, portrayed by Joaquin Phoenix in Joker, is a complex character. He’s an underdog mistreated by the welfare system, and abused by just about everyone else. This makes us care about him – yet his ambiguous position as a good AND evil character is what makes him memorable.
Send in the clowns…
Clowns have always been dual-faced figures: they use comedy AND tragedy to get their laughs. Often, the audience is even invited to laugh at their misfortune – albeit with the assumption that everything will be OK in the end.
It’s a tried-and-tested formula handed from medieval jesters, and made brilliant by Charlie Chaplin, arguably the world’s most beloved ‘sad clown’.
Chaplin’s Tramp character appears in several films, including Modern Times. As you’d expect from the name, he’s poor, hungry and down-on-his luck. Terrifyingly, that makes him the punchbag for society villains – rich men with moustaches – who do their best to trample him even further.
These grim circumstances are played for laughs, yet balanced by the Tramp’s determination to stick up for himself and those worse off than him (usually women or children).
The Tramp represents the best of human nature – though one heavily tinged by the American dream and medieval religion. In other words: be self-reliant, be good, and “smile though your heart is aching” (lyrics added retrospectively to music used in Modern Times).
Joker mirrors Charlie Chaplin films
Chaplin features heavily in Joker, albeit from a distance, like Arthur Fleck’s shadow. Most noticeable, is the use of the song Smile (see the trailer). Modern Times is also shown being screened.
Fleck, of course, sees himself as a Chaplin figure, a man put on Earth to make others laugh. And, with a nod to the Tramp, we see him crying through his clown make-up as the movie opens, literally painting a smile over his aching heart.
Fleck is a clown, too, as in that’s his day job. He also wants it to be his night job, in that he wants to be a stand-up comedian. Unfortunately, he’s just not funny.
Like the Tramp, Fleck lives in abject poverty but cares for others – notably his mother. He’s similarly ignored and misunderstood by society, and physically beaten for being down-on-his-luck.
And, like any Chaplin movie, Joker is stuffed with slapstick elements: Arthur’s buffoonish run, his hyena-like laugh, the misfired gun, and the ‘pie’ in the face (which is actually a board). However, just as Fleck isn’t funny, the prat falls are played straight.
This mix of pain and almost-comedy sets Fleck up as a tragic figure that we can’t help but care about. He stands for the homeless or lonely guy in the street that society chooses to ignore. On the big screen, his circumstances and childlike mannerisms make it easier to see it all for what it is: injustice. All of this makes Arthur Fleck the underdog – just like Chaplin’s Tramp.
Arthur Fleck is ‘Batman’
Arthur Fleck could have been a superhero. Specifically, he’s the Batman that never was.
When Fleck finally snaps and shoots his tormentors on a subway train, it’s a move that both repulses and inflames Gotham. As with Batman later on, some citizens see this masked vigilante as a dangerous menace, while others see him as the city’s saviour.
The ‘dark Batman’ angle is given further prominence by the suggestion that Thomas Wayne is Fleck’s father too, making Arthur and Bruce brothers.
The movie resolves this tension as a red herring – but it could be true. As significant portions of Arthur’s life are imagined, it’s possible he also imagines that what Wayne tells him about being adopted is true. He’s nothing if not an unreliable narrator.
What does it mean when Joker dances on the steps?
The stairs that lead to Arthur’s home are key to a central concept in Joker. As Fleck, Arthur trudges wearily up them every day. At the top lies the life he’s always known: poverty, loneliness, and looking after his mother. His journey upwards represents his battle against his external circumstances, and his internal struggle to be good.
Later, as Joker, he dances down the same steps. Once he stops trying to be good, and embraces the ‘path to hell’, life becomes much lighter.
There are other reversals like this, each of which reveal Fleck’s ambiguity as both hero and villain (or, if you like, as a man pushed too far, like Michael Douglas in Falling Down).
Arthur cares for his mother with incredible tenderness; but later he smothers her without hesitation. Similarly, he invents a romantic relationship with his neighbour, only to terrorize her in real life once the Joker’s personality breaks free.
The infernal struggle
The internal struggle is key to understanding Fleck, and it erupts in all the wrong places – like his uncontrollable laugh.
The laugh resonates, because no one else laughs at Fleck’s jokes. This reveals the cruelty of the phrase “laugh and the whole world laughs with you”, and underlines his loneliness. There’s also nothing remotely funny about Fleck’s situation: his overblown laughter is a spotlight that shows just how humourless his situation is.
For Fleck, the laughter is a visually uncomfortable tic, one that he tries to stifle. Later, he comes to embrace it – and his murderous nature – as his true self.
At the start of the film, Fleck cries while making himself up as a clown. At the end, he wears his make-up like war paint and does a victory dance on the steps. Having resolved the internal struggle, Arthur is no longer hiding behind a mask, but revelling in it as his true persona.
This is where the line – the ambiguity between good and evil – stops. Coming down the stairs as Joker kills off the good inside him (Arthur) and embraces the dark and chaos. The only way is down.
Picture credit: Yong Chuan